Seamore Butts Is Not the Problem

The latest hysteria over fraudulent voter registration cards is an overblown reaction to a minor issue. The stories about bad voter registration cards are hyped as indicators of insidious election fraud coordinated to tilt the election in one candidate's favor. The Plain Dealer and some other media outlets have been in a tailspin recently over problems with a small number of voter registration turned in to Cuyahoga County by ACORN.

A story in the PD about the voter registrations in question describes the situation but finally manages to provide some much needed context as to what is happening in Cuyahoga County. As you could have guessed the amount of names in question is minimal, the story by Joe Guillen indicates 50 out of 65,000 cards turned in have problems. According to my slide rule that would be a staggering 0.08% (I'm even rounding up) of registrations turned in to the elections board. The cards were already flagged by board employees so it's not a voting issue. Even the normally bitchy pants Rob Frost, Chairman of the Cuyahoga County GOP wasn't overly concerned, from the PD:

But even Chairman Rob Frost, the second Republican member on the county's election board, said the potentially fraudulent registration cards do not jeopardize the fairness of the election.

His opinion on the lack of severity of the matter was seconded by the other Republican member of the Cuyahoga County BOE, Jeff Hastings. The consensus seems to be that the bad registrations are a result of a sloppy operation on the part of ACORN's staff not a concerted effort to have everyone vote three times. That understanding over the ACORN voter card issue has been lost on the McCain Campaign. Seeing another line of attack McCain and his advisors have begun to link Obama to the group and it's alleged diabolical scheme to register fake voters. If you were part of the flailing John McCain campaign you'd probably do the same thing. Claiming that a few erratic voter registration cards threaten the election process isn't an honest assessment of the real problems facing voters.

A story written by Dennis Willard appearing in today's ABJ highlights the true threat to free and unfettered elections. In his account the Greene County (Ohio) Sheriff had taken up the banner of fighting election fraud. What made this case disturbing was the Jim Crowe era tactics attempted by a elected law enforcement official. As Willard points out Sheriff Gene Fischer took it upon himself with no evidence of apparent wrong doing (only rumors) to start investigating the names of the 300 or so persons who early voted in Greene County. Fischer's requests involved seeking the public and non public information of the people who early voted. Presumably the names would include some of the students attending two historically black universities that are located within the County. The arbitrary and seemingly biased way that this "investigation " was started is enough to sound the tocsin over voter suppression:

This ill-conceived act is enough to raise questions about Fischer's understanding of the law and his sensitivity to ensuring that voters —especially African-American voters — feel secure and not threatened by exercising their fundamental rights, but his ineptitude did not occur in a vacuum.

The context Willard refers to is the importance of Ohio in this election and the issues that demobilizing voters, be they black or white through intimidation and suppression could have on the outcome.

The real problem with elections in swing states like Ohio is and has always been voter suppression and purging of voter roles. Unlike registration drives from outside groups these two menaces are abetted by the government bodies charged with protecting our most important franchise. A dark and inequitable force that seems to gravitate around poor and working class citizens in economically depressed areas.

Just in the past few weeks there have been stories of attempts to purge voters from the rolls in Michigan, Colorado and even in Ohio (no way). The story is repeated every four years and the purging always seems to zero in on minority and poor voters. In fact Michigan officials were going to attempt to challge voters who's homes had been foreclosed on and thus had outdated mailing addresses. Who can forget the voter challenging drives and caging lists in Ohio in 2004? That round of voter suppression was brought to you by the Ohio GOP and the fomerly important Ken Blackwell. An exhaustive story by Robert Kennedy Jr. detailed the damage caused to the fairness of Ohio's voting system in 2004.

Clearly the likes of Seamore Butts, Hugh Jass, Heywood Jablome and the Dallas Cowboys pose only minor nuisance for election board staff trying to sort through voter registrations. Troubles from phony registration cards pale in comparison to the damage caused by system enforced voter purging and suppression that rears its head every four years. I've said before the only sure way of overcoming this undemocratic influence is through the Powell Doctrine of overwhelming force. The crushing wave of support for candidates like Obama and the disdain for more Bush era policies will provide that force on election day.

If you get the chance check out Greg Palast's new web site and comic book called Steal Your Vote Back. Vote early vote often once.

Powered by ScribeFire.