Wall St. Turd Could Sink Akron Sewer Plan

I really appreciate Michael Douglas' enthusiasm in yesterday's editorial on the bright prospects of the Akron Sewer system lease plan. Douglas whom doubles as the ABJ's editorial page editor when he's not extolling the virtues of the greater NEO region's economy thinks the time is right for leasing the City sewer system. Never mind that the financial markets are facing turmoil not seen in generations and credit is drying up faster than the Aral Sea. The Douglas piece actually points to the failing capital markets as a sweetener to completing a lease deal:

If anything, the arrangement is just the kind of pedestrian deal that investors could use, no credit default swaps, no derivatives, no financial instruments that baffle even Ben Bernanke. What appeals to investors is the steady flow of revenue, a chance to bolster the foundation of their operation.

Last I read and heard nobody wants to lend anyone money for any reason, no matter how "pedestrian" the project happens to be. As commonly mundane as public infrastructure appears to be the area of leasing public assets to private entities is still relatively new. Once again the allure of free education for Akron's youth (use of funds) has overridden the need to actually consider the potential pitfalls (source of funds) of a lease agreement.

The potential for a $200 million dollar fund that a lease deal would generate will continue to shrink as the concessions are heaped on to make it voter acceptable. The Mayor has already mentioned limiting rate increases, maintaining staffing and continuing capital improvements to the system as requirements for a potential lease deal. These will all detract from the ability of a private company to actually make money on their end of the deal and lessen the chance of finding a suitor.

Before the City can even get to the point of creating a higher education fund linked to a leasing deal the dynamics of the market will have to change considerably. Transferring public assets into the realm of private debt has already lost its cache after the events of the past week. Consider this observation from Naomi Klein writing on the condition of the free market ideology post meltdown:

For years, the global investment banks have been lobbying politicians for two new markets: one that would come from privatizing public pensions and the other that would come from a new wave of privatized or partially privatized roads, bridges and water systems. Both of these dreams have just become much harder to sell: Americans are in no mood to trust more of their individual and collective assets to the reckless gamblers on Wall Street, especially because it seems more than likely that taxpayers will have to pay to buy back their own assets when the
next bubble bursts.

In the end the idea of combining the Akron Sewer System with another regional governmental entity is the safest way to go. Not just safe but downright pedestrian.


Powered by ScribeFire.